05 March 2020

Back to brioche — and butter content

Yesterday I went out on a brioche hunt and excursion. I had kept thinking about what CHM said about finding brioche in a pastry shop — une pâtisserie — rather than a bread bakery — une boulangerie — to get brioches that less resemble breads and are more cake-like. The place I had in mind was a bakery in the village of Lye [lee], which is only 15 minutes east of Saint-Aignan by car.


The Lye bakery is one I've gone to for bread several times on the way to or back from the bigger town of Valençay, and it seems to be the one around here that makes and sells the most complete range of breads and pastries. For example, I've seen (but not bought) pain de mie there, while in most bakeries that's something you don't always find. It's a "hybrid" shop and called a boulangerie-pâtisserie (as are many of the bakeries around Saint-Aignan), but focused more on breads than pastries.

As so often happens here in rural France, when I got to Lye I found the bakery shut up tight. The big metal shutter was pulled down, and there was a hand-written sign taped to it. I didn't stop to read the sign, and I hope that the bakery is just closed temporarily, not permanently. It didn't matter all that much yesterday, because I was on my way to Valençay anyway. I wanted a couple of things from the Intermarché over there, including, if I could find one, a loaf of brioche de Nanterre like the one I enjoyed a couple of weeks ago but haven't found again.

To make a long story short — something you might have noticed I'm not very good at — there I was in Lye, four miles from Valençay, at 8:30 a.m. I wasn't sure what time the Intermarché store would open its doors, but probably not before 9. I happen to know that there are at least two bakeries in Valençay, so I thought I'd go see what they had for sale. I needed bread anyway. At the first one, near the famous château de Valençay, what did I find but little individual brioches in the Paris style:-They're little crown-shaped cakes with a "head" — a little knob of the same dough stuck on top (see photo above).


I got four of those, two baguettes (above), and a croissant for the road, and then I headed for Intermarché. It was still not even 9 o'clock, and when I drove into the parking lot there I saw no cars there at all. But there was a big sign listing the store's opening and closing times on different days of the week — very complicated as such schedules can be only in France — and I saw that on Wednesdays the store opened at 9:15. Oh well. That would give me time to go and check out the second bakery in Valençay, which is nearby. And I'm glad I did.






The second bakery was very atmospheric. It was open for business, but appeared dimly lit because the windows were completely steamed up with condensation. It was cold outside, and I guess the oven in the back room of the bakery was producing a lot of steam, which was condensing on the big plate-glass window. The first thing I saw was four or five huge, tall, brown breads or cakes of some kind standing on a tray on top of the pastry counter. As you can see from the photos here, they looked almost like pieces of stove pipe, but with a swirl pattern  in the pastry (see below).

And there was a hand-written sign next to them. Brioche feuilletée. 4,50 €. Wow. Just what I was looking for. A woman came into the shop from the back room, greeted me cheerfully, and asked how she could help me. I'll have one of those brioches, I told her.





Then I noticed a bread that the sign said was called a marguerite and asked for one of those too. Marguerite [mahr-guh-REET] means "daisy" — you can see from my photo why it's called that. It actually looks like a pan of American dinner rolls.

Anyway, one more thing: CHM said in a comment a couple of days ago that the brioche he remembers has more or less that same texture as a croissant. It's not really like bread (even though the brioche made in the Vendée is very bread-like, in American terms). I happen to have in my collection of cookbooks a two-volume set called Jacques Pépin's The Art of Cooking (1988). I was looking at those books the other day to see if Pépin includes a recipe for brioche. Among other things, I read the following in his segment on making croissants, pains au chocolat, and brioche: "Croissant dough is a cross between puff paste [pâte feuilletée in French] and brioche. It's a flaky dough that is rolled and folded like puff paste but contains yeast." That's confirmation of the similarity of true brioche to croissants mentioned by CHM.

However, Pépin writes about brioches that they are "buttery, light breads [not cakes] made from moist yeast dough." His brioche is made with a generous pound of flour, a pound of unsalted butter, five large eggs, and two egg yolks, plus yeast and salt. It's rich. Meanwhile, the 1967 edition of the Larousse Gastronomique food encyclopedia gives different recipes for the true brioche called brioche mousseline, which it describes as un gâteau levée (a leavened cake), as well as for brioche commune and brioche ordinaire. All three varieties start with 500 grams of flour, but the amount of butter is very different. The dough for brioche mousseline contains 400 grams of butter and six eggs; for brioche commune, 250 grams of butter and six eggs; and for brioche commune, 200 grams of butter and just four eggs. That's a lot more butter than they put in the loaves of bread-like brioche vendéenne sold in supermarkets. Look closely at the toasted slice of brioche feuilletée and you can see the melted butter that has oozed out of it. It makes good toast that you don't need to butter — just serve with confiture.

Today is my birthday, and I guess brioche will be my birthday cake. Unless Walt decided to make a cake while the blanquette de veau I'm preparing for my birthday lunch simmers on the stove.


50 comments:

  1. Happy Birthday! You certainly found some intriguing and delightful looking brioche on your travels today.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I wonder if I ever asked you this very off topic question before. It came into my mine as I was reading your blog post....My grandmother and her twin sister were born in April, 1904. They were named Marguerite and Madeleine for characters in a French book their mother was reading before their birth. I would love to know what that book might be, but no one has ever had any ideas. Do you have any thoughts about this?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Could it be this book? It was published in France in 1858. I haven't been able to find an English-language version. Maybe your great-grandmother read French?

      Delete
    2. Thank you so much! She did read French. I will get this English version which you found. So exciting!

      Delete
    3. And I found it at amazon.com because I was afraid the French Kindle version would not work on mine. Thank you, and again, Happy Birthday!

      Delete
  3. Wishing you the happiest of birthdays!! The brioches here look very tasty. The French seems to be very specific and descriptive about the names for different foods in a way that Americans are not...if I can generalize.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Happy Birthday & Bon Appetit, Ken!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Joyeux anniversaire ! Vous devenez un spécialiste de la brioche... bravo et bon app !

    ReplyDelete
  6. The first photo shows brioches as I remember them from decades ago!

    In the industrial so called Brioche Vendéenne and others, the content of butter is probably kept to a minimum to make the product profitable but still edible!

    I didn't know there were so many kinds of brioche depending on the butter content versus the amount of flour. The more butter the fluffier the brioche. Right?

    I also had no idea brioches could be made with .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Probably, Google didn't like my html and dropped it. Here it is, if it wirks this time pâte feuilletée.

      Delete
    2. I don't know what kind of dough that stovepipe brioche is made from, but in truth is is too buttery. Eating it unheated, I didn't so much enjoy it. I toasted it, but I was afraid butter might drip out of it and muck up the inside of the toaster. I think I'd rather have the Vendée brioche as a breakfast bread.

      Delete
  7. Oh, gracious, HAPPY BIRTHDAY dear Ken! What a joy you give us every day with your posts!
    This one was so interesting to me, and I loved imagining you just tooling around the countryside, popping into a nice bakery and getting to see these fantastic options. I hope you're having a wonderful day!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It was fun to drive over to Valençay, but also sad to see so many shuttered storefronts there. The town has been experiencing hard times for 20 years now. Even so, both the bakeries I found had very good brioches and breads. I especially liked the little round brioches with the knob of dough baked on top. Not too buttery, not at all dry.

      Delete
  8. Happy Birthday indeed!

    I'm surprised you haven't mentioned viennoiserie, which is the in-betweeny category that brioche falls into. Boulangeries can make viennoiseries but they can't make patisseries unless they have the extra qualification.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Most of the boulangeries around here are listed under the category boulangerie-pâtisserie. Brioche doesn't seem to be a viennoiserie, though croissants are.

      Delete
  9. Happy Birthday! Oh what beautiful bread!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Happy Birthday Ken.From a reader who started three dogs ago. Dennis Martin

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nice to hear from you, Dennis. Yes, it's been a three-dog life.

      Delete
  11. I hope you have enjoyed your birthday with brioche and banquette. Your day out and about sounds like a good birthday adventure. Thanks for keeping us informed about brioche and all things French.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Happy Birthday Ken. And it's so nice that you can stop at a couple of random bakeries and get such wonderful looking items. We have a few very good bakeries in Maine, but it takes some planning to buy from them, because of geographic and time/day limits. By the way, I've made the pumpkin brioche recipe you posted numerous times. It's among the best brioche I've ever eaten. Maybe the best.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I remember that pumpkin brioche being very good too. I'm thinking of making a loaf of it using sweet potato instead of pumpkin.

      Delete
    2. I've made that brioche with squash rather than pumpkin right from the start. Of course, a pumpkin is a squash. Also, I make it in muffin tins rather than as a loaf. I get 8 individual brioches out of that recipe.

      Delete
    3. I too might have made the "pumpkin brioche" with winter squash like sucrine du Berry. I like the muffin pan idea and will have to try it that way.

      Delete
    4. I had never heard of sucrine de Berry before, so I looked it up. It's an old traditional squash from the Berry region of France (of course, hence the name). And I found that the seed company that I recently bought seeds from for another heirloom squash variety also carries Sucrine de Berry, so maybe we'll try it in our community garden.

      Delete
  13. All the best Birthday Greetings to you, Ken!

    OMG, what gorgeous bread!

    ReplyDelete
  14. A very Happy Birthday, Ken!! Looks like it's going to be a very special day, as it should be...and many more.....

    DR

    ReplyDelete
  15. Happy Birthday, Ken! May you and Walt have many more years in happiness together! Roderick

    ReplyDelete
  16. Looks delish! Happy Birthday!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Joyeux Anniversaire, Ken! A perfect day for me in France is to visit a couple of patisseries and a boulangerie, as well! Making it more perfect is to find just what one is searching for! Like you did! I was curious when you said, "...and a croissant for the road!" Now I know why!

    BTW, I keep forgetting the answer to your question a while back! That Brie I bought was from Ile de France so it could have been from Melun!

    I hope your day was the best birthday, yet! You deserve it!

    Mary in Oregon

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mary, the Ile de France Brie you buy in the States is US made, supposedly according to an original French recipe. I buy it at Harris Teeter, a Kroger's supermarket here in Arlington, Virginia. Considering, it is not that bad, but there is no comparaison with the real French thing! So Melun has nothing to do with it! Neither has Meaux nor Coulommiers!

      Delete
    2. Unfortunately the "real French thing" is rarely the real French thing anymore in France. If it says Brie de Meaux or Brie de Melun it is likely to be very good. But most French brie you see now is very ordinary, and produced in enormous quantities. It's gone the way of Camembert. A true Camembert de Normandie can be outstanding, but there's lots of very mediocre Camembert.

      Delete
    3. When in France I stick to Selles-sur-Cher goat cheese, Comté, and Le Rustique camembert which I really like and can recommend. It's one of the best, in my opinion. I can find it in Arlington from time to time. Contrary to Ile de France, it is made in France and imported.

      Delete
    4. Mary, I don't eat croissants very often, but sometimes when I'm out and about early in the morning, as I was the other day, I'll stop at a boulangerie and pick up a croissant to enjoy while driving or walking around. I get crumbs all over my clothes and the seat of the car, but who cares? I didn't know Ile de France still existed. I remember it from Washington DC in the '80s, if it's the restaurant chain I'm thinking of. I'm out of touch with the French cheese situation in the U.S., but I agree with Bob that it's not a sure thing to be able to find really good Brie or Camembert in France nowadays, at least not in supermarkets. But then for all the 50 years I've been spending a lot of time in France, it has always important (and normal) to open up the Camembert box and feel how soft or hard the cheese is before you decide to buy it. And smell it! I don't know if you can do that in the U.S.

      Delete
    5. The restaurant chain you're thinking about was Vie de France, not Île de France. I used to buy my baguette there every night after work on my way to the subway and home. I don't think it exist anymore.

      Delete
    6. Oh, right. By the way, I read in Julia Child's books that brioche commune, which is made with a dough containing about 15% butter by weight, is the same thing as what is called pain brioché. The Vendée brioche that I found so good was 15% butter. I'll buy it again. True brioche, or brioche fine, is over the top at 30% butter by weight. Then there's brioche ordinaire, with a butter content of 20%.

      Delete
    7. Chm, I consider Selles sur Cher to be one of the best cheeses in the world, along with similar goat cheeses in the Loire (e.g., Valencay). It used to be available in the US, but I haven't seen it here in a long time. Comte is generally quite good. Although most of them are made by large cooperatives, I guess their standards must be high.

      Delete
    8. Ken, I don't know about the IdF Camembert, but as for the Brie, nowhere in sight, on the packaging, does it say, Product of France. On their site, Iledefrancecheeses.com it says that a three-kg wheel is produced in Lorraine (is that a small region of Wisconsin?).

      The Ile de France cheeses are distributed by the French group Savencia. It also distribute the Le Rustique Camembert on whose box it says Fabriqué en France. So why no mention on the Brie's box?

      I Googled 13.2 oz Ile de France Brie cheese and here is what I got:
      Original French recipe. Ile de France was the first brie ever imported to the United States in 1936 aboard the elegant Ile de France ocean liner. Today, our brie still represents the best of French cheese making tradition. Gluten free. Product of USA.

      Confirming what I already said!

      Delete
    9. Lorraine is a town in Ohio! I like Le Rustique Camembert, and there are several others that are good, but you have to choose carefully and cross your fingers that it will be good when you pay for it. At least here Camembert is inexpensive, between 1.50 and 3.00 euros per cheese. I wonder how much you pay for a Le Rustique Camembert in the DC area.

      Delete
    10. I haven't seen a Le Rustique Camembert for quite a while now so I don't know how much it is. But the 13 oz American Ile de France Brie, about the size of a regular Camembert, is 12 dollars + tax, which is expensive for a non-French item. I just have a small piece at the end of my lunch everyday, so it lasts about 10 to 12 days! As I said, for an American product it is not bad at all, considering!

      Delete
    11. Today, for lunch, I opened a new box that was in the fridge and the price on it was $15.99 + tax ! That's not cheap, is it?

      Delete
  18. Thanks, everybody, for the birthday wishes. It was an awful day weather-wise — really gusty winds and hard downpours of rain — but I enjoyed it anyway. The blanquette de veau à ma façon came out really good, as usual. This time I added some cubed turnip and parsnip to the pot, along with carrots, onions, and mushrooms. Lots of veal broth and lots of cream...

    ReplyDelete
  19. Happy (belated) birthday, Ken! The stovepipe-shaped brioche feuilletée is made by laminating brioche dough, which is already enriched with butter, with butter, like croissant dough. That's a lot of butter!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the explanation, Tom. All that butter gives me heartburn. Same applies to croissants, especially if I have coffee with them. Hope you and Harriett are both doing well.

      Delete
  20. Replies
    1. Thanks, C. Hope you and A. are doing well.

      Delete
    2. Right now I am in Palm Springs, but heading to Paris the last week of the month, unless a government entitiy tells me I can't go. Taking my niece and grand niece, who are both 19. Indoctrinating them into travel....while they are young.

      Delete

What's on your mind? Qu'avez-vous à me dire ?